Badger InstituteBadger Institute
  • Home
  • Issues
    • Taxes
    • Education
    • Crime & Justice
    • Spending & Accountability
    • Economy & Infrastructure
    • Licensing
    • Healthcare
    • Civil Society
  • Mandate for Madison
  • Research
  • Magazines
    • Diggings
    • Wisconsin Interest
  • Events
  • Media
    • Podcast
    • Fact Sheets
    • Viewpoints
    • Press Releases
    • Badger in the News
    • Video
    • Audio
    • Testimony
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • Board of Directors
    • Team
    • Visiting Fellows
    • America’s Future
    • Careers
  • Newsletter
  • Donate
  • Contact Us

Subscribe for Updates

Get the latest news and updates from Badger Institute.

What's New

Wisconsin lawmakers in the dark on broadband

March 16, 2023

The underfunded part of Wisconsin public schooling

March 16, 2023

If we don’t pay for roads, we don’t get mobility

March 9, 2023
Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn Instagram
TRENDING:
  • Wisconsin lawmakers in the dark on broadband
  • The underfunded part of Wisconsin public schooling
  • If we don’t pay for roads, we don’t get mobility
  • Assembly Speaker calls for tolling to fund Wisconsin infrastructure
  • Foreseeing the Future of Wisconsin’s Flat Tax
  • Amid illiteracy, where was the urgency?
  • Calls to Police from MPS High Schools Up Dramatically Again
  • Wisconsin voters will be asked about welfare work requirements
  • Donate
  • Newsletter
  • Contact
Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn Instagram
Badger InstituteBadger Institute
SUPPORT OUR MISSION
  • Issues
    • Taxes
    • Education
    • Crime & Justice
    • Spending & Accountability
    • Economy & Infrastructure
    • Licensing
    • Healthcare
    • Civil Society
  • Mandate for Madison
  • Research
  • Magazines
    • Diggings
    • Wisconsin Interest
  • Events
  • Media
    • Podcast
    • Fact Sheets
    • Viewpoints
    • Press Releases
    • Badger in the News
    • Video
    • Audio
    • Testimony
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • Board of Directors
    • Team
    • Visiting Fellows
    • America’s Future
    • Careers
Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn
DONATE
Badger InstituteBadger Institute
Home » Culture Con: Madison school district assumes it knows best
Education

Culture Con: Madison school district assumes it knows best

By Richard EsenbergOctober 15, 2019
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest

The district adopts a policy that keeps parents in the dark about their gender-transitioning children

T.H. White’s 1958 novel, “The Once and Future King,” tells the story of a mythical ant colony governed by a single aphorism: “Everything which is not forbidden is compulsory.” He might have been speaking of the 21st-century social-justice left.  

A movement that initially called for greater tolerance for diverse identities and lifestyles increasingly has insisted on conformity to a narrow orthodoxy. A recent example can be found — where else? — in Madison, Wisconsin.

In April 2018, the Madison Metropolitan School District adopted a 35-page policy addressing the treatment of transgender students. It provides that any student of any age may change gender identity at school by selecting a new “affirmed name and pronouns” to be used at school “regardless of parent/guardian permission” and without medical or psychiatric confirmation of the student’s gender dysphoria.

Not only must all teachers and district staff refer to students by their “affirmed” name, district staff is forbidden from revealing “a student’s gender identity to … parents or guardians … unless the student has authorized such disclosure.” Not only must parents not be informed, they apparently must be deceived: The policy directs teachers to use “the student’s affirmed name and pronouns in the school setting” and to switch back to the student’s “legal name and pronouns with family.”

It is not my purpose here to litigate the notion of “gender identity” as something divorced from biological gender. My concern is the absolutism with which the district has approached the matter.

Exhibiting the intransigent close-mindedness that increasingly characterizes the cultural left, it assumes that affirmation is the only proper response to any claim of any child to “be” something other than his or her biological gender. Nothing else — not the child’s age or the possibility that this claim may be arise from unrelated emotional issues — matters. The involvement of a child’s parents is not only unnecessary but presumptively harmful.

This is, to put it bluntly, a form of fundamentalism. What the district calls a “student-centered” approach is more about ideology than any thoughtful consideration of the particular children charged to its care. It is a matter of doctrine.

‘Divergent views’

Here are some facts. The vast majority of children who experience gender dysphoria (some estimates are as high as 80% to 90%) ultimately resolve it in favor of their biological sex. This has led many medical and psychological professionals to support treatment designed to first help gender-dysphoric children learn to embrace their biological sex. They argue that automatically “affirming” an alternate gender identity too early can become self-reinforcing.

Put differently, the choice of treatment can determine the outcome. If you believe that transitioning to another gender can be a difficult path accompanied by bad outcomes, “false positives” are worth worrying about.

Other health professionals believe, as with the Madison schools, that the appropriate response is to “affirm” a child’s perceived gender identity. But even in this “affirming” camp, there is no consensus on whether young children should transition socially to a different gender.

The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), a transgender advocacy organization, acknowledges that “social transitions in early childhood” are a controversial issue about which health professionals have “divergent views” and that existing evidence at this point “is insufficient to predict the long-term outcomes of completing a gender role transition during early childhood.”

Consequently, WPATH advises health professionals to “counsel and support” parents even if the parents ultimately decide “not (to) allow their young child to make a gender-role transition.”

In light of this, you’d think the Madison district would want to involve a child’s parents. We normally — and rightly — presume that parents have their child’s best interest at heart. We understand that they know their child better than anyone else. We recognize that parents ought to be the principal decision-makers with respect to a child’s health care, education and socialization.

We generally acknowledge the primacy of the family and permit the state to intervene in parental decision-making only when there is a particular reason to suspect that harm will occur in the absence of such intervention.

But not in Madison. And not when an 8-year-old boy claims to be a girl. The Madison school district has turned our normal presumptions inside out.

Even as it seeks to displace traditional religious perspectives — perhaps because it seeks to displace them — the social-justice left has taken on a Messianic character. Madison’s transgender policy assumes that district bureaucrats are in possession of a revealed wisdom that is not shared by the families it purportedly serves.

The parents of children who seek to transition are presumed to be in error, and the district, echoing the 19th-century Pope Pius IX, has declared that error has no rights. What was once to be tolerated has become the new orthodoxy. Everyone in the colony must conform.

Richard Esenberg is president of the Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty, which is asking the Madison district to repeal the policy before WILL considers a legal challenge. UPDATE: On Dec. 18, WILL sent a letter to the district saying it will sue the district unless the policy is changed within 45 days.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Telegram Email
Richard Esenberg

Related Posts

The underfunded part of Wisconsin public schooling

March 16, 2023

Amid illiteracy, where was the urgency?

February 23, 2023

Family finds education freedom a “godsend”

February 16, 2023
Categories
Top Posts

Local pols filling old budget holes with massive COVID aid

December 8, 20221,447

This is not four years ago

November 10, 20221,283

A state without convictions

January 12, 2023643

Billions in federal spending in Wisconsin unaudited; results never measured

November 9, 2022484
Archives

Sign Up for Top Picks

Our weekly e-Newsletter with the latest items and updates

Connect with Badger Institute
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
About Us
About Us

The Badger Institute is a nonpartisan, not-for-profit institute established in 1987 working to engage and energize Wisconsinites and others in discussions and timely action on key public policy issues critical to the state’s future, growth and prosperity.

Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube LinkedIn

Sign Up for Top Picks

Our weekly e-Newsletter with the latest items and updates

What’s New

Wisconsin lawmakers in the dark on broadband

March 16, 2023

The underfunded part of Wisconsin public schooling

March 16, 2023

If we don’t pay for roads, we don’t get mobility

March 9, 2023

Assembly Speaker calls for tolling to fund Wisconsin infrastructure

March 2, 2023
© 2023 Badger Institute | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Sitemap

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

This site uses functional cookies and external scripts to improve your experience.

Privacy settings

Privacy Settings

This site uses functional cookies and external scripts to improve your experience. Which cookies and scripts are used and how they impact your visit is specified on the left. You may change your settings at any time. Your choices will not impact your visit.

NOTE: These settings will only apply to the browser and device you are currently using.

CRM Software

Customer Relationship Management Software

Google Analytics

Google Analytics is a web analytics service offered by Google that tracks and reports website traffic. Google uses the data collected to track and monitor the use of our Service. This data is shared with other Google services. Google may use the collected data to contextualize and personalize the ads of its own advertising network.

You can opt-out of having made your activity on the Service available to Google Analytics by installing the Google Analytics opt-out browser add-on. The add-on prevents the Google Analytics JavaScript (ga.js, analytics.js, and dc.js) from sharing information with Google Analytics about visits activity.

For more information on the privacy practices of Google, please visit the Google Privacy & Terms web page: https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en

Powered by Cookie Information