Underly budget would deny disabled children the opportunities given other students
Suppose you were the parent of a child with a disability. You’d want a good education for your child, but you’d also find yourself caring about the environment in which that learning took place. You’d want other kids taught to respect your child’s dignity, to think of her as a gift, not a burden.
“Our regular education students learn so much from having special education students in the classroom,” said Drew Mulloy, headmaster at St. Ignatius Catholic School in Kaukauna. “That’s a real gift to have that as a part of our school.”

Weirdly, a state bureaucracy wants to snuff that out.
St. Ignatius stands out for a couple of reasons, one being its proactive welcome to children with disabilities. It started, said Mulloy, as a way for families to keep siblings together in the K-12school, even siblings with special needs. About 14 percent of the school’s 244 students attend via Wisconsin’s Special Needs Scholarship Program, which lets about $16,000 in state aid follow a disabled child to an independent school.
“We’re proudly pro-life in our morals and values, and one way we can live that out is by accepting all children into our school,” said Mulloy. That includes students with Down syndrome and language delays and other disabilities.
“We place a deep emphasis on how kids are growing in virtue, in kindness, in their faith, and teaching them right in the classroom how to be accepting of all kids is a very important value for us,” he said.
The school also offers a “classical curriculum,” part of a national movement to eschew fads in favor of the true, the good and the beautiful. Kids read Dante and Sophocles. They discuss both in Socratic seminars. They learn spelling. They’re taught math the way math was taught for centuries. The second language is Latin.
It’s rigorous.
“There’s a deep emphasis on classroom discussion, memorization, recitation, and those are things that kids with disabilities can certainly participate in fully,” said Mulloy. When kids bear a disability label, he said, “it’s easy to put limits on them, but they’re really capable of so much.”
Nah, says the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction: No more of that.
When state Superintendent Jill Underly unveiled her budget request this week, one flashing red light was that she’d kill off the Special Needs Scholarships entirely, allowing no new students in after next school year. No new schools could start letting in disabled kids.
Even as Underly’s proposal would increase special education funding in district schools by about 91 percent over last year because “state funding has not kept pace with rising costs,” the grant that parents could take to schools like St. Ignatius or 231 others would be frozen.
“Public schools are the best place for students with disabilities to learn because public schools accept all students,” said a DPI spokesman, defending the policy aimed at ensuring that any other school would bankrupt itself if it went on accepting such students.
St. Ignatius enrolls families who drive in from Shiocton and Oshkosh, 28 miles away, because they “really put a high value on wanting their kid in a safe, faith-filled environment,” said Mulloy. Such families might dispute whether the DPI — which managed to misspell its own name in its budget proposal — indeed knows what’s best for their kids.
The agency, in its budget request, also wallops parental choice programs for non-disabled kids, cutting grants for high-schoolers to $12,552 per child, then freezing them, asking the Legislature to sever a link with rising public school aid. Meanwhile, per-child revenue to school districts, already averaging nearly $19,000 per child, would leap by nearly $1,000 and get automatic increases thereafter. Underly also would freeze per-pupil funding in independent charter schools and give herself the power to kill their authorizer.
But the door she would first slam shut entirely is the one serving the most vulnerable kids. Why?
Her proposal doesn’t explain. Bewildered parents can only speculate.
Perhaps it’s because the program is a small part of school choice, serving just under 3,900 kids this fall, 6 percent of the 63,300 Wisconsinites who take their state aid to a private school via choice, and the DPI feels any outrage will be commensurately small.
Maybe it’s because the program puts lie to a perennial attack on school choice: Critics claim private schools don’t take disabled children. The charge has been refuted repeatedly, and the Special Needs Scholarship lets schools defy such critics. St. Ignatius employs five special ed teachers, said Mulloy.
Critics like to claim, as that DPI spokesman did, that private schools are redundant. But no district in Wisconsin duplicates the Socrates-and-cursive classical curriculum that gets families to drive from Oshkosh. Who is the DPI to say parents are wrong to want it?
For that matter, simply switching to another school district is difficult under Wisconsin’s open enrollment laws, since districts can reject incoming disabled students. It was just such denials that prompted state Sen. John Jagler (R-Watertown) to come up with the Special Needs Scholarships in the first place, he said: Parents “were stuck in situations in schools that weren’t fitting their kids’ needs.”
If the next Legislature, with a majority that’s shown opposition toward school choice, or Gov.-elect David Crowley, who avoids saying he supports it, go along with Underly’s proposal, parents will go back to being stuck.
And for what? What public good would be served by forbidding parents from affording an option that comes in thousands cheaper than regular ed in districts? Is there any value, aside from letting a troubled bureaucracy assert that it, not parents, knows what’s best?
Mulloy said parents hear from others with disabled kids, “and many of them will find us saying, ‘We’re so thankful.’”
What’s wrong with that?
Patrick McIlheran is executive editor at the Badger Institute.
Any use or reproduction of Badger Institute articles or photographs requires prior written permission. To request permission to post articles on a website or print copies for distribution, contact Badger Institute Marketing Director Matt Erdman at matt@badgerinstitute.org.

