Wisconsin has the highest obesity rate among neighboring Midwestern states
While Wisconsin’s new governor, David Crowley, will have many priorities, overseeing Wisconsin’s implementation of recent federal changes to the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program known in Wisconsin as FoodShare, should be among the top.

Wisconsin, reacting to federal changes in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), passed a FoodShare reform and financing bill in March 2026. This measure provides additional funding to help the state meet new federal requirements for FoodShare, including expanded work requirements and program integrity efforts. It also required the Department of Health Services (DHS) to apply for a waiver from the federal government to restrict the purchase of certain candy and soft drinks with the use of FoodShare dollars, which DHS has not yet done.
The new administration must follow through on placing restrictions on FoodShare purchases in accordance with the law. Wisconsin has the highest obesity rate among neighboring Midwestern states. Even though FoodShare is likely only a small part of the problem, low-income families in Wisconsin suffer disproportionately from obesity and government policies should support good nutrition, not subsidize unhealthy foods.
Twenty-three other states that have already received waivers from the federal government to limit the definition of foods eligible for purchase. Eight states are currently implementing the waivers, with prohibited items largely including sweetened beverages, other soft drinks, and candy. The federal Food and Nutrition Administration tracks pending and approved food restriction waivers, and Wisconsin is not yet listed.
Emerging evidence points favorably to these waivers reducing the purchase of restricted items and possibly aiding in the consumption of fewer calories from these products among SNAP participants. Three separate studies have recently examined purchase data among SNAP recipients in the 10 states that began restriction pilots in January 2026. All three studies found a decline of around 12 to 13 percent in the purchasing of restricted items, including soda, energy drinks and candy. One study also found reductions in calories associated with such restricted products.
It may seem intuitive that restricting the use of SNAP benefits for certain items will reduce their purchase. However, many economists have long argued the fungibility of SNAP benefits. This argument rests on the assumption that any restrictions would simply lead to the purchase of prohibited items with cash. The conclusion: Any policies that restrict SNAP purchases for the purpose of reducing unhealthy items are futile.
Although the early evidence does not completely undermine the fungibility argument, it does demonstrate that SNAP restrictions can change purchasing behavior. SNAP participants did not replace restricted SNAP purchases with cash purchases, as many expected.
This is an important first step in assessing the effectiveness of SNAP restrictions, but it is not the only one. Further research is needed to understand whether SNAP restrictions alter the overall nutritional profile of foods purchased and consumed — and whether any changes in purchasing behavior lead to better health outcomes. This creates an opportunity for Wisconsin policymakers to evaluate whether FoodShare restrictions can improve health outcomes for low-income populations. As part of the waiver request, Wisconsin’s DHS must propose an evaluation. In light of the early evidence, Wisconsin’s DHS should prioritize assessing the policy’s effects on nutrition and health outcomes, including the consumption of restricted items, overall caloric intake, and any changes in the overall nutritional profile of SNAP participants.

Assessing the effectiveness of SNAP restrictions is particularly important for Wisconsin. According to the United Health Foundation’s assessment using data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Wisconsin has the highest obesity rate among neighboring Midwestern states and ranks poorly among states. The obesity rate in Wisconsin is worst among low-income adults, suggesting that they are particularly vulnerable to the health issues associated with obesity and likely have the least resources to address it.
Through a rigorous evaluation, Wisconsin can be a leader in providing evidence about food restriction policies, helping to inform whether they improve nutrition and diet quality or not. This requires identifying a rigorous comparison group, utilizing existing grocery store data, and surveying both people who use SNAP and those who do not. By incorporating such design elements, Wisconsin can contribute substantially to the existing evidence base.
The current experience of states that have already implemented these waivers, alongside the existing evidence, places Wisconsin in a strong position to design and implement a useful pilot.
Angela Rachidi, a Badger Institute visiting fellow, is also a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), based in Washington, D.C. In her work, Rachidi studies the impact of safety net programs on low-income families and individuals. She researches the effects of government policies and programs on employment, child wellbeing, family income and economic mobility.
Any use or reproduction of Badger Institute articles or photographs requires prior written permission. To request permission to post articles on a website or print copies for distribution, contact Badger Institute Marketing Director Matt Erdman at matt@badgerinstitute.org.

